Haunted Prison

The state of Ohio is home to many things: Buckeye trees, the first professional baseball team, and the Rock and Roll Hall of fame, but what about supernatural beings? Well, it turns out the Buckeye State has its fair share of creepy locales, some of which may be home to a paranormal entity or two. Here are a few notable haunted places in Ohio that will send chills up your spine.

Haunted House of Wills in Cleveland

The Haunted House of Willis

If there’s any place on this list that would house a ghostly spirit, it’s this place. Once a massive funeral home – and before that, it was a German Opera house – the haunted House of Wills in Cleveland is now a derelict building filled with crumbling ceilings and relics from the past. In 2010, it was purchased by a High Priest of the New Church of Satan in the hopes of renovating the 34 room mansion. Tours are available on the Church’s website for anyone who wants to experience a walk around the ominous building. People have reportedly witnessed strange mists, and some have even claimed to have seen the ghost of J. Walter Wills, the previous owner who died in the mansion back in 1971.

Haunted Franklin Castle in Ohio City

Haunted Franklin Castle

Located in Ohio City, Franklin Castle appears as a beautifully designed Victorian home but is known as one of the most haunted locations in the Buckeye State. Franklin Castle was built in the 1880s by a banker named Hannes Tiedemann. The castle proved to be a curse for Tiedemann since many of his family members – including his mother and four of his children – died in the house. In the past few decades, there have been reports of people hearing sounds of babies crying and seeing a mysterious woman in black roam the hallways. Today, Franklin Castle is privately owned – which means no trespassing folks – but anyone curious about the building can view it from the sidewalk.

Fairport Harbor Haunted Lighthouse

The Haunted Fairport Harbor Lighthouse

What’s a list of haunted locations without a creepy lighthouse? The Fairport Harbor Lighthouse was first completed in 1825 and is referred to as “The Light that Shone for 100 Years.” Today it serves as a marine museum that houses a number of artifacts and maritime exhibits. It is also home to Sentinel the ghost cat. Legend has it that one of the previous headmaster’s of the lighthouse gave his bedridden wife numerous cats to keep her company. Unfortunately, she passed away soon after and many of her cats left – except for one gray cat. Some say the cat is still there – albeit in spectral form – with one curator claiming to have seen the cat skittering across the floor near the kitchen.

Ohio State Reformatory

The Haunted Ohio State Reformatory

If you’re a fan of the 1994 film The Shawshank Redemption, then this place will look very familiar to you. Also known as the Mansfield Reformatory, The Ohio State Reformatory is a massive prison complex located in Mansfield, Ohio. Construction on the foundation started on November 4, 1886, and was designed by Cleveland Architect Levi T. Scofield, who envisioned a building with gothic architecture so unnerving that it would encourage inmates to leave their criminal tendencies behind. Today, the prison is said to be quite haunted by the ghosts of the past. The haunted prison offers ghost tours and hosts a haunted attraction each Halloween for any brave customers who hope to capture a glimpse of spirits who are still imprisoned within the building’s walls.

The Haunted Grounds of Mudhouse Mansion

The Haunted Mudhouse Mansion

Haunted Mudhouse Mansion before being demolished in 2015.

This next haunted location is unfortunately not around anymore, but nevertheless, it has become a legend amongst locals for its ghostly stories. The Mudhouse, located in Fairfield County, Ohio, was a towering mansion that became a hotspot of spooky lore amongst locals. For decades, people would trespass on the property to wander the building’s crumbling walls and hope they’ll leave with a frightening story to tell – perhaps they’ll hear voices of small children or a figure roaming the hallways. Due to years of trespassing and the amount of money needed to renovate it, the owners of the Mudhouse decided to tear it down. Although gone, some Fairfield County locals keep the legend alive by passing down stories of the ominous building to future generations.

Lorain Palace Haunted Theater

The Haunted Lorain Palace Theater

The Lorain Palace Theater, located in Lorain County, Ohio, is one of the oldest movie theaters in the state. Opened in 1928 to much acclaim, the theater was one of the first in Ohio to play talking pictures. Due to its rich legacy dating back to the early 20th century, it’s no surprise that there have been a few instances of ghostly activities lurking about the theater. Paranormal investigators claimed to have spoken with the numerous spirits whose lives tragically ended at the establishment. One spirit, who said his name was Ed, worked at the shipyard – which was located behind the palace – until he was murdered when he was pushed down the stairs. Another spirit said they had died from a heroin overdose, while many others were killed when a tornado hit the county back in 1924. For those further interested in the Theater’s unexplained activity, a documentary was made about the Lorain Theater Palace by a group of local paranormal researchers.

More Haunted Ohio

Real Haunted Places in Ohio

Top Haunted Attractions in Ohio

Address

  • : Ohio, USA
  • Visiting a haunted prison is creepy enough, especially one featured in many popular TV shows and movies. But that’s just the beginning. This prison also houses one of Hollywood’s elite horror makeup artists in Robert Kurtzman. This triple threat is exactly what you’ll get when you visit the Paranormal Penitentiary in Mansfield, Ohio. With the help of Kurtzman they are transforming the Ohio State Reformatory into a monster mecca of epic proportions.

    Paranormal Penitentiary: Monster Lockdown

    Believe me, this isn’t your run of the mill haunted house experience. In fact, before you can enter Paranormal Penitentiary: Monster Lockdown you must first become a member of “Slayers of the Damned,” a super secret society dedicated to the pursuit of hunting, capturing, and containing the world’s worst monsters. (Don’t tell anyone though; it’s a secret.)

    As you make your way through this 400,000 square-foot facility you will experience the kind of unimaginable terror usually found only in nightmares. There are monsters hiding in every dark corner and abandoned cell, while others roam the halls looking for fresh meat. What makes the Paranormal Penitentiary so terrifying is the fact that you are walking through a real prison that has housed thousands of America’s worst criminals. Many believe some of them are still haunting the halls.

    Haunted Ohio State Reformatory

    Ohio State Reformatory

    Standing outside Mansfield, Ohio since 1834, the Ohio State Reformatory is an impressive Gothic style structure that looks like something out of Transylvania. It’s a perfect place for creatures of the night to do their dirty work. As with most prisons, violence was a common occurrence, including murder. In 1926, a correctional officer was shot to death, and in 1932, another officer, working in solitary confinement was beaten to death with an iron rod. These are only a couple of the many deaths at OSR. Today the prison is known to be haunted by many of the souls lost in the prison walls. There are even sightings of a woman walking along a pond leading to the prison, known as the Ghost of Reformatory Road.

    This prison may seem familiar to you (even if you didn’t spend hard time there). That’s because the OSR has been featured in movies going back to 1976 when Harry and Walter Go To New York was filmed at the prison. Never heard of it? That’s okay. How about Tango and Cash with Sylvester Stallone and Kurt Russell? And you’ve likely seen The Shawshank Redemption!  This classic Stephen King story was turned into the most rented and purchased movie of 1995. It is so beloved with moviegoers that many fans take part in the The Shawshank Trail. Here you get to visit 14 filming sites from the movie and experience some of what Andy and Red did. Minus the beatings.

    Robert Kurtzman - Creature Corps

    Robert Kurtzman

    What makes a great haunted house even greater? Robert Kurtzman, that’s who! You would be hard pressed to find anyone who hasn’t seen his work. Kurtzman has been creating movie magic for years. Whether it’s doing makeup, writing, directing, or producing, he has been part of it all. He has had his hand in everything from Dances With Wolves and Jingle All the Way to horror classics like Wishmaster and Army of Darkness. You might be asking yourself, “Why go from Hollywood movies to haunted houses?” The truth is, Kurtzman has had his own haunted attraction for years in Ohio and decided that he’s ready for a new challenge. FrightFind had the opportunity to talk with Kurtzman about the change and pick his brain about the state of Hollywood today.

    FrightFind: So how did you get involved with the Paranormal Penitentiary?

    Robert Kurtzman: They came to us looking for a new feel to the haunt. Something unique. They wanted more monsters and their storyline was intriguing.

    FF: When you do something like this are you constantly trying to one up yourself? Are you going bigger and better?

    RK: The prison is really the draw. We are just trying to fill it with more creatures. Everything is original. It’s stuff we worked on at the studio Creature Corps as well as work from other local artists.

    FF: What should we look for when touring the prison?

    RK: You will see lots of cool original monsters as well as some you know. We have some unique new things like actors in walk around alien suits. You know, like the dinosaur suits that are popular now. They look really cool.

    FF: Will you be dressing up as a monster too?

    RK: No, I don’t do that. I will be there though, saying hi and signing autographs. It should be fun.

    FF: This must be a busy time for you, with Halloween around the corner and several movies coming out. What should we look for?

    RK: We finished work on Kevin Smith’s Yoga Hosers, which will be coming out in select theaters August 30th. Kevin is out promoting it now. We should start working on his next film, Moose Jaws, a little later. Besides that I have several other movies I’m working on. I finished up a movie called The Neighbor that will be coming out soon. I think everyone is really going to like it.

    RK: I also have a film coming out in December called Bye Bye Man. This one is going to be scary.

    FF: What do you think about all of the remakes and reboots we have been seeing lately? Do you like the idea of rehashing old beloved movies?

    RK: It depends. I hear they are rebooting Nightmare on Elm Street. It could be really good, but if it doesn’t have a twist it isn’t going to work. I watched Ghostbusters and liked it, but it definitely wasn’t the original. I thought they did a good job casting all of those great comedic actresses. But no matter what they do, it just can’t hold up to the original.

    FF: Have you had a chance to watch Netflix’s Stranger Things?

    RK: I loved it! I binged watched it. I thought it was really cool. I loved seeing all of the old movie posters and catching all of the references to the classic 70s and 80s films. The music was really great too. Like I said, I loved it.

    FF: One last very important question. What kind of candy do you hand out at Halloween?

    RK: Oh man, we have a huge bowl of everything. Candy bars, candy corn, everything. The only thing I don’t give out are those peeps. None of that marshmallow crap!

    Peeps are gross