The Bloody Benders Family of Oklahoma

, KS   /   0 Reviews

montgomery County and Labette County, Kansas

While there are conflicting theories and questions as to who the first serial killer was, we here at FrightFind have an even bigger one for you. Who was the very first family of serial killers? The Sawney Bean Clan is an Irish true-crime legend, and the numbers and victim count are hard to verify. The Kelly Family of the Midwestern United States actually had a trap door built under a chair at the dinner table to dump victims’ bodies to their deaths, but even then the death tally is marginal. Just who was the biggest and worst serial-killing family on the planet? That grotesque notoriety goes to none other than the Bender Family of Labette County, Kansas. And guess what? Their infamous house is now for sale, and you can be the lucky owner of one of the bloodiest places in serial killer history.

Who were the Bloody Benders Family?

The Bloody Bender Family

The Bloody Bender Family

Back in 1870, homesteading was still the primary way many Americans owned land. Given away totally for free by the United States government, millions of acres were up to anyone who applied. Among the more socially awkward and unappealing applicants was a German immigrant family by the name of Bender. Late middle-aged patriarch John Bender Sr. and his wife Elvira were able to secure over one hundred and sixty acres upon which they could build their dream farm. John Sr. spoke almost no English (opting almost always for his native German), and what little came out was in guttural forms that were likened to that of a vicious dog barking. His wife, Elvira, barely spoke anymore English than he did, and her demeanor and personality were so mean-spirited and vicious that many people who met them believed her to be Satan’s wife in the flesh. Along with the homesteading farm build was John and Elvira’s only son, John Jr. Most surviving accounts recollect John Jr. to be in his twenties with a shock of red hair and a joker-esque personality. Also with the family was their only daughter, Kate. In great contrast to her parents and brother, Kate was reported to be extremely attractive and spoke English perfectly.

An image of the Bloody Benders' inn.

An image of the Bloody Benders’ inn.

In 1871, the Benders opened up a roadside inn adjacent to their Parsons, Kansas property. Their murderous gimmick was later revealed in the national newspapers to be quite simple. Wayward travelers or spiritualists would be lured inside. It was known throughout the town of Parsons that Kate was often seen hanging up flyers advertising her psychic readings and seances that she would hold at the inn. Inside the inn, a table or bench on which a victim sat would have a very simple canvas curtain inconspicuously strung up behind them. Having the room lit with a typical oil lamp of the time and ready for a reading or seance, the victim’s guard would be down. Behind the curtain would be standing either John Sr. or John Jr., who would then take a sledgehammer and bash the unsuspecting victim in the head from behind. With their skull crushed and brains oozing out, Kate would then produce a knife to slit their throats to ensure their total death before Elvira stripped them of all their money.

Bodies were kept in the basement area and eventually buried out into the family orchards. The Benders were able to keep up their bloody serial killing ways for nearly two years until they came across their final victim. Dr. William York was a man who went calling on the Benders in the Spring of 1873. When he never returned, his brother, Colonel Ed York, and Kansas State Senator Alexander York, organized a search party to find their brother. Suspecting the Benders, the York brothers procured warrants to raid the property. Upon seizing the property, the Benders escaped; however, with what the York brothers found, they simply couldn’t give chase.

What happened to the Bloody Benders?

The graves of the Bender Family's victims.

The graves of the Bender Family’s victims.

Bodies were buried in the basement of the inn (which was difficult to breach since the hinges were rusted over with clotted human blood), while out in the orchards, even more victims were found. Most had crushed skulls, others multiple stab wounds, and some even were evidenced as being buried alive. Eleven bodies were officially tagged by officials, while twenty-one more were partially confirmed. Across the property were other body parts that could never be claimed, thus revealing the true number of unsuspecting victims at the hands of the Bender family to be never truly known. In their hasty escape, the Benders were able to successfully evade capture for their crimes. One of the most prevailing theories is that John Sr. and Elvira later fled to Minnesota while John Jr. and his sister Kate went to Texas. One of the posse members, Colonel York, made a deathbed confession that Kate was captured and set on fire in a ditch right there in Kansas, burned alive for her crimes at the hands of vigilante justice. Her remains were never found.

Through the ages, the property itself was surprisingly maintained, and the 152 acres of former bloody Bender property has been put up for sale by the Schrader Real Estate and Auction Company of Kansas. But do you know what the most terrifying and chilling downside to owning this piece of serial-killing family history is? The land the bloody Benders once roamed has never been fully, and totally, excavated! Are there remains? Whatever happened to the Benders? For now, only the supernatural heavens know.

Love this article? Read more on FrightFind’s blog. 

Posted in Haunted Hotels and Real Haunts

Add a Review

Rate this by clicking a star below:

Related Listings

(401) 849-3600

26 Marlborough St, Newport, RI 02840, USA

Is The White Horse Tavern Haunted? In 1673, The Whitehorse Tavern opened its doors in the Rhode Island Colony making it the oldest bar in the country. Throughout the centuries, the tavern has been used as a boarding house and British military quarters during the Revolutionary War. It’s no surprise that with all the activity in the tavern over the years, several ghosts have been seen by guests. A poplar spirit being an elderly man who died while renting a room above the bar in the early years of The Whitehorse Tavern. Read more…